Vital Football

Latest Sheffield Wednesday News

Stadium Name Blame Game

Stadium Name Blame Game

Newcastle United owner Mike Ashley might have unwittingly found the best way to create total unity amongst Toon fans.

St James' Park is the third largest club stadium in England. It's the largest ground in the Championship. It has the largest cantilever roof in Europe. The top corner of the Milburn Stand is the vertiginous peak of all the stadiums of England.. you can get no further away from any football pitch and still stay seated, unless you own a helicopter. Opened in 1892, it has a glorious history. It's iconic.

And yet, as we all know, Ashley has ignored the history and substantial local strength of feeling (you'd think he's have learnt his lesson by now) and re-named it sportsdirect.com@StJames'Park. The unity he's created unfortunately means that everyone hates that name, and him for changing it.

Is it really modern and forward thinking, incorporating both tradition and commercial considerations?

Or is it crass, insensitive, lowest-common-denominator scum-sucking greed? That may be your view, and I'm guessing that would be the majority of Wednesday fans' feelings on first hearing the news.

It's the re-naming we have a problem with, isn't it? If you're going to build a new stadium, you are casting aside years of past history but you're boldly going forward into a new era, so it's less of a problem. I don't think there was a tenth the amount of fuss over, say, the Emirates Stadium (there may be some who call it Ashburton Grove, I dunno) because it was new. Highbury is a fond memory for Arsenal fans. The Emirates was the future, and is well established now in hearts and minds.

And looking around the world at similar deals, Newcastle fans got off lightly. York City play at the rather chocolatey KitKat Crescent. The University of San Diego men's basketball team plays at the Jenny Craig Pavilion, sponsored by Kirstie Alley's favourite weight loss guru. MLS soccer team FC Dallas play at Pizza Hut Park. The NFL's Pittsburgh Steelers play at the saucily named Heinz Field. FC Nuremberg from the Bundesliga play at EasyCredit-Stadion (at least until 2011 when the deal is up for renewal).

But that news won't make a St. James' Park name change any easier to bear for the Toon Army. They're livid, and rightly so.

But hang on a minute, let's not get indignant, let's pause a moment for reflection. Here's a thought. We know the coffers at Sheffield Wednesday are in need of replenishment. Investment in the club is on the far distant horizon, no matter how hard Lee Strafford, Nick Parker and the club are working to attract it.

So if Wednesday re-named Hillsborough, and it meant that Brian Laws could pay for an extra season-long loan of a Premiership player (another Franck Songo'o, for example) would you throw away your principles and be happy that the Owls grabbed the cash from stadium naming rights? Or would you be up in arms, picketing the club, waving your placards and protesting at the sacrilege?

Scroll down to the bottom right corner of this page, and cast your vote. We'd like to know what you think.


Win FREE pizza with Vital Football!
Select your team and get 50% off if they score twice.
www.papajohns.co.uk/football



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Auckland Owl
Date:Tuesday November 10 2009
Time: 12:00PM

Best of Vital Network

Comments

0
No, it should always be hillsborough, i dont like how all these other clubs whore themselves for the next pay day. Besides, knowing wednesdays luck, it would probably be something stupid like the tampon stadium.
DEZZYP
10/11/2009 12:42:00
0
To be honest I find all this renaming malarkey a bit stupid. Sportsdirect.com@st james park? Ashley is having a laugh, however the only traditional stadium I believe should be renamed should be hillsborough. My reason is that the hillsborough name will always be associated with the tragic events 20 years ago. I'm not proposing anything as daft as pizza hut park, but I for one wouldn't be too upset to be going to a corporately named stadium. I will still be watching the game from the same seat in the same stadium. Who knows, getting rid of the hillsborough name may attract other investors, and if nothing else, the club will have some money.
tomawest
10/11/2009 16:25:00
0
id accept Hillsborough Fifa stadium, or some other football game related names
w4rn3r
10/11/2009 19:02:00
0
has anyone noticed the sign that's says ' sheffield united fc academy' - this way out side swillsborough? or as for renaming your ***** hole..swillsborough would be very fitting!!!
bladesforlife1889
11/11/2009 00:27:00
0
can someone explain how pigs have convinced everyone they have an injury crisis to excuse being crap? only 2 players from Barnsley game prob wouldnt be first XI, and thug Morgan was banned, having a few squad players and loanees out with niggles and they act like nobodies ever had as many injuries
wesp
11/11/2009 01:13:00
0
Has Blackwell noticed the sign that says 'This way to the Job Centre' yet, bfl?
Auckland Owl
11/11/2009 01:14:00
0
hope your right auckland but with 21 injuries what do you expect him to do? funny thing is all said and done and taking into account our shocking injury list we are still above you sorry lot which is so amusing and must really hit home how crap you lot really are? as for the sign im not pulling your plonker here, its a fact go and have a look - its awsome - well done sheffield city council!!
bladesforlife1889
11/11/2009 11:34:00
0
whats that sign got to do with owt bfl personally i couldnt care less im a fan of all acadamies i for one would be very proud if my kids got to play for one even the blunts so re read the thread and then make reasonable comments or feck off
bradford_owl
11/11/2009 12:27:00
0
A point above us with a worse goal difference, bfl? Oh that's definitely something to be proud of.
Auckland Owl
11/11/2009 18:46:00
0
21 injuries?????????????
wedtillidie
11/11/2009 20:10:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Sheffield Wednesday Articles

He's magic you know … But it's time for Semedo to go

He's magic you know … But it's time for Semedo to go Quite literally, Jose Semedo is a club legend at Sheffield Wednesday!

Vital Match Preview - Wednesday Vs Cardiff City (April 30th)

It's VITAL you read this preview before the BIG match this weekend

Vital Match Comments - Carlos Rallies #swfc Fans!

Carvalhal has urged Wednesdayites to help his players over the line

Match Day Officials - Wednesday Vs Cardiff City

Who's the man in the middle of Wednesday Vs Cardiff?

Archived Vital Wednesday Articles

Vital Wednesday articles from

Site Journalists

Ed Jepson
Editor email
Profile
Josh Alex Caddick
no email
Profile
Greg Pursehouse
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Will Wednesday seal their Playoff Spot against Cardiff?
Suggested By: @JoshAlexCaddick
Yes, have NO fear...89%
No, we always do things the hard way!11%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Middlesbrough 45 26 10 9 88 32
2 Burnley 44 24 15 5 87 33
3 Brighton 44 24 15 5 87 30
4 Hull City 44 23 11 10 80 31
5 Derby County 44 21 14 9 77 24
6 Sheff Wed 44 18 17 9 71 19
7 Cardiff 44 17 16 11 67 8
8 Ipswich 44 16 15 13 63 0
9 Birmingham 45 16 14 15 62 4
10 Brentford 44 17 8 19 59 -2
11 Preston 44 14 16 14 58 -1
12 Leeds Utd 44 14 16 14 58 -7
13 Q.P.R. 44 13 18 13 57 0
14 Wolves 44 13 15 16 54 -6
15 Reading 44 13 13 18 52 -4
16 Huddersfield 44 13 12 19 51 -3
17 Forest 44 12 15 17 51 -5
18 Blackburn 44 11 16 17 49 -3
19 Rotherham 44 13 10 21 49 -13
20 Bristol City 44 12 13 19 49 -20
21 Fulham 44 11 15 18 48 -11
R MK Dons 44 9 12 23 39 -28
R Charlton 44 8 13 23 37 -38
R Bolton 44 4 15 25 27 -40
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Sheffield Wednesday Results (view all)

Sheffield Wednesday Fixtures (view all)

Apr 30 2016 3:00PM : Cardiff City (H)
Sky Bet Championship
May 7 2016 12:30PM : Wolverhampton Wanderers (a)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.dooleys left leg8
2.adelaideowl2
3.Fantham's Hairnet1